Term vs. Whole Life Insurance: Costs, Pros & Cons
Term covers you for a set number of years and costs a lot less. Whole life covers you for life and builds cash value, and you pay much more for it. This is how I’d think it through.
On this page
- 1. The short answer
- 2. Term life
- 3. Whole life
- 4. Universal, variable and indexed life
- 5. Side by side
- 6. Buy term and invest the difference
- 7. What the price gap means
- 8. Which one I’d look at
- 9. Questions people ask
- 10. Talk it through with me
If your only life insurance is through work
Group life through your job is a good thing to have, and it’s usually cheap or free. I just wouldn’t count on it as your only coverage, for three reasons.
It usually ends when the job does. Quit, get laid off or retire, and the coverage goes with it. You can usually turn it into an individual policy without answering health questions, but only for a short window, and at a much higher price. In Florida, the law gives you 31 days after you leave to apply and pay, and the policy is priced at your age then (Fla. Stat. 627.566).
Your employer picks the terms. They choose the insurance company, the amount and the features, and your beneficiary options may be limited. The amount often doesn’t keep up as your income and your family grow.
And the amount may not be enough. Work coverage is often a flat amount or a multiple of your salary, picked for everyone at once. Few people ever check it against what their own family would need. It’s worth checking now, while you can still add to it.
What I’d do
Don’t drop the work coverage. Keep it, and add a term policy of your own on top. Yours stays with you whatever happens with the job.
I work through how to size the number for your own household in a separate guide, with the arithmetic shown.
Term vs whole life: the short answer
Term life insurance covers you for a set number of years, usually 10, 20 or 30. If you die in that time, your beneficiaries get the death benefit. If you outlive it, the policy ends. It costs a lot less.
Whole life insurance covers you for your whole life, as long as you keep paying, and part of each premium builds cash value you can borrow against. For the same death benefit it costs much more.
If you’re buying to protect a family through your working years, term usually fits better. Whole life makes sense when you need coverage that never runs out, for final expenses or an estate plan, or when you’ve already filled your other tax-advantaged accounts.
Most of the time it comes down to two questions. How long will someone depend on your income? And what premium can you keep paying for that long? The carriers I work with are listed on their own page.
What is term life insurance?
It’s the simplest kind. You pick an amount and a length, usually 10, 20 or 30 years. On a level-premium policy the price stays the same for the whole term. To see how term life fits with the rest of your coverage, take a look at how working with me goes.
The good part is the price. It’s the cheapest way to buy a big death benefit, and it’s easy to understand. It also lines up with things that end, like a mortgage or kids living at home.
The downside is that it builds no cash value, and when the term ends, so does the coverage. If the policy lets you renew, renewing costs much more because you’re older. If you need coverage after that, you pay for it at your age and health then.
What is whole life insurance?
Whole life is permanent coverage with a savings piece built in. The premium is usually level for life. Part of it goes to cash value, which grows on a schedule the policy guarantees, and you can borrow against it. Some policies are participating, which means they can pay dividends, but dividends aren’t guaranteed.
What you get for the higher price: coverage for life as long as premiums are paid, with no need to qualify again. Cash value you can borrow against for an emergency or an opportunity. And a savings habit whether you like it or not, since part of every premium goes to cash value. People use it for final expenses and to leave something behind.
What it costs you: a much higher premium for the same death benefit, so most budgets buy a lot less coverage with it. The cash value grows slowly in the first years. And the policy is harder to understand than term, so read the illustration before you sign.
How whole life is taxed
Three parts of the tax treatment matter. The cash value grows tax-deferred, so you don’t pay tax on it each year as it builds. The death benefit generally isn’t income to your beneficiaries (IRC Section 101), with exceptions, such as a policy that was sold to someone else. And a policy loan generally isn’t taxed while the policy stays in force. If the policy lapses or is surrendered with a loan on it, or it’s a modified endowment contract, tax can come due. Your tax preparer can tell you how that applies to you.
What about universal, variable and indexed life?
These are other kinds of permanent coverage. You’ll hear about them, so I’ll cover each one briefly.
Universal life
Universal life lets you change your premium and your death benefit, within limits. The cash value is credited at interest rates the insurer sets, above a guaranteed minimum. The flexibility is the point. The risk is that if you pay in less, or the credited rate stays low, the policy can need more money later to stay in force.
Variable universal life
Variable universal life puts the cash value into sub-accounts you pick, a lot like mutual funds. It can grow faster, and it can lose value. It’s the most complicated of the bunch, and it’s sold as a security, so it comes with a prospectus.
Indexed universal life
Indexed universal life credits interest based on a stock market index, like the S&P 500, without putting your cash value in the market. A floor limits what you lose when the index falls, and a cap limits what you’re credited when it rises. Read the guaranteed column of the illustration, not just the projected one.
For most people, the real choice is still term vs whole life insurance.
Term vs whole life side by side
| Term life | Whole life | |
|---|---|---|
| Price for the same coverage | Lower | Much higher |
| Coverage for the same premium | More | Less |
| How long it lasts | The term you pick | Your whole life, while premiums are paid |
| Cash value | None | Yes |
Should I buy term and invest the difference?
This is probably the most argued-about question in life insurance. The idea is simple. You buy term life insurance and invest the difference, meaning what you would have spent on whole life goes into a 401(k), an IRA or a regular brokerage account instead. Your insurance and your savings stay separate.
Term costs less than whole life for the same death benefit. The difference is money you keep, and what it turns into depends on what you do with it.
Whole life builds cash value on the schedule in the carrier's illustration, the year-by-year table the insurer gives you with a quote. That illustration is the only number worth reading, and it comes from the carrier, not from me.
You won't find a projected cash value or a projected investment return on this page. I can't stand behind either one, so I don't print them.
When it works
It works if you’ll actually invest the difference, every month, for years. It works if you can live with your account going up and down with the market. And it works best when your need for coverage has an end date, like once the mortgage is paid off and the kids are on their own. You also keep more control. You can get at your money without a policy loan, and you get more death benefit for the same monthly cost.
When whole life still makes sense
Plenty of people mean to invest the difference and never get around to it. Whole life does the saving for you. Investments aren’t guaranteed, and whole life cash value grows on a schedule you can read before you buy. If you’ll still need coverage after the term ends, buying it then costs much more at your age. The tax treatment helps too, since cash value grows tax-deferred and loans generally aren’t taxed while the policy stays in force. And it fits if you’ve already maxed out your 401(k) and IRA, or you need permanent coverage for an estate plan or final expenses.
Why is term life insurance not worth it?
The usual complaint is that if you outlive the term, the policy never pays. That’s true. It’s also true of car insurance when you never have a wreck.
Term is the wrong fit if you need coverage for life, because you may not qualify for a new policy later, or if you want cash value. For most families, though, it’s the only way to afford enough coverage during the years they’d need it, and what you don’t spend on whole life stays yours. The need usually shrinks as the mortgage gets paid and the kids grow up, and term is built for that.
Can I have both term and whole life insurance?
Yes, and plenty of people do. It’s called layering. A small whole life policy covers the needs that last, like final expenses. A bigger term policy sits on top for the years your family depends on your income, like the mortgage or childcare. You get a lot of coverage when you need it most and some that never runs out, for less than whole life alone would cost.
What happens to my term life insurance when I turn 65?
Turning 65 doesn’t change anything by itself. What matters is where you are in the term. If the term has already ended and the policy has a renewal provision, you can renew it year to year at much higher rates, or let it lapse if you no longer need it. If the term is still running, the coverage keeps going at the same price until it ends. And if the policy has a conversion option and you’re still inside its window, you can convert to permanent coverage without a new medical exam.
What the price gap between term and whole life means
For the same death benefit, whole life costs a lot more than term, month after month, for as long as you pay.
What you don't spend is yours. What whole life builds instead is cash value, on the schedule in the carrier's illustration, and that illustration is the only number worth reading. If you're weighing the two, bring it to the call and I'll walk through it with you.
Which one I’d look at
I’d look at term if you need a lot of coverage for the least money, if what you’re covering has an end date (a mortgage, kids at home), if you’d rather invest on your own, or if the budget is tight.
I’d look at whole life if you need coverage for life, if you have an estate plan or final expenses to cover, if you want cash value that grows on a guaranteed schedule, and if you can keep paying the higher premium for the long haul.
Questions people ask
Can I convert term life to whole life later?
Often, yes. Many term policies have a conversion option that lets you switch to permanent coverage without a new medical exam. It only works inside the window the policy sets, so check it when you buy.
Is whole life insurance a good investment?
I'd call it insurance with a savings feature, not an investment. Part of each premium builds cash value on the schedule in the carrier's illustration, and that illustration is the only number worth reading. Term costs less for the same death benefit, and the difference is money you keep. Whole life earns its place when you need coverage for life, want the forced savings, or have already filled your other tax-advantaged accounts, not because of a projected return.
What happens when my term policy expires?
You can let it lapse if you don't need it anymore. If the policy allows it, you can renew year to year at much higher rates. Or, if it has a conversion option and you're still inside its window, you can convert to permanent coverage. Check the renewal and conversion terms when you buy, not when the term ends.
Should a 30-year-old get term or whole life insurance?
For most 30-year-olds, term fits better. Most of what you'd be covering, like a mortgage or childcare, doesn't last forever, and term gets you the most coverage for the money during those years. What you don't spend on whole life is yours to keep. Whole life at 30 can make sense if you have a child with special needs who'll need care for life, if you earn a lot and already max out your retirement accounts, or if there's a family business to pass on.
If you’re in your twenties or early thirties, What Changes When You Buy Life Insurance Later goes through what changes when you wait.
Want to talk it through?
Term or whole life comes down to what you’re protecting, for how long, and what you can comfortably pay. It’s easier to sort out in a conversation than with a formula.
What we’ll do on the call
Book a time
30 minutes, and no pressure to buy
Book 30 minutes with meI'm the one who calls, at the time you pick. I don't sell your information or pass it to other agents.
Before choosing a carrier, read Life Insurance Company Ratings: Financial Strength Explained for what an AM Best rating does and doesn't tell you. You can also read more on my life insurance page.
Zach Bradford
Florida license W347851 • NPN 18181266
I'm Zach Bradford, an independent broker licensed in 8 states, Florida, Michigan, North Carolina, Arizona, Texas, Georgia, Indiana, and South Carolina, for health and life insurance only. I've been licensed since November 2016 and with Best Insurance Group since September 2021. When you call, you talk to me, not a call center.
