Back to Resources

COBRA or Private Health Insurance? What to Pick if Healthy

Leaving a job usually means a COBRA letter shows up, and the price on it is a shock. If you’re healthy and your household makes too much for a subsidy, COBRA isn’t your only choice. What trips people up is timing. You get 60 days from losing the job plan to pick a HealthCare.gov plan instead, and if you take COBRA and drop it early, you don’t get that window back.

By Zach Bradford, Licensed FL Broker W347851November 16, 2026Current as of November 16, 2026

This page is for readers in the 8 states I’m licensed in: Florida, Michigan, North Carolina, Arizona, Texas, Georgia, Indiana, and South Carolina. It’s general information, not legal advice.

Just got your COBRA letter?

Have it handy when we talk. On a 30-minute call I’ll put the COBRA price next to a full-price HealthCare.gov plan in your county and the private plans I can sell in your state, while you’re still inside your 60 days.

Book 30 minutes with me

I'm the one who calls, at the time you pick. I don't sell your information or pass it to other agents.

What COBRA is, and why it costs so much

COBRA lets you keep the health plan you had at work after you leave, usually for up to 18 months when you lose the job. Same plan, same doctors. It applies to plans from employers with 20 or more employees.

The price is the part people don’t expect. While you worked there, your employer probably paid much of the premium. On COBRA you can be charged the whole thing, up to 102 percent of what the plan costs, which is the full cost plus 2 percent for administration. That’s the number on the letter.

How long can you stay on COBRA?

Usually 18 months when the job ends or your hours are cut. It doesn’t matter whether you quit, were laid off or retired. The only exception in the law is being fired for gross misconduct. If Social Security finds you were disabled in your first 60 days on COBRA, it’s 29 months, as long as you tell the plan in time. A spouse or child can get 36 months after a divorce, the worker’s death, or a child aging off the plan. Retiring at 63 means 18 months gets you to 64 and a half, not to Medicare, so plan the last stretch now.

How much is COBRA per month?

Your letter has your plan’s real number, but here’s a yardstick. KFF’s 2025 survey of employers puts the average yearly premium for job-based coverage at $9,325 for one person and $26,993 for a family. At 102 percent, that’s about $793 a month for one person and about $2,294 a month for a family.

Is COBRA cheaper than a marketplace plan?

Over the subsidy line, it can be close. In Miami-Dade County the benchmark HealthCare.gov silver plan for 2027 is $742 a month at full price for a 40-year-old, near that average COBRA bill. At 60 it’s $1,576. Put your own COBRA number next to what HealthCare.gov shows for your age and ZIP code.

A short-term plan can come in under both, if you’re healthy. When I priced 12-month Allstate Health Solutions plans in Hillsborough County, Florida on November 19, 2026, the one with a $5,000 deductible that pays 80 percent after it was $426 a month for a 40-year-old man and $891 at 60. It can turn you down and usually won’t cover conditions you already have. My Florida guide has the full table, women included.

Can I pay COBRA from my HSA? Yes. COBRA premiums are one of the few insurance premiums a health savings account can pay tax free. A marketplace plan’s premiums usually aren’t, unless you’re getting unemployment benefits. If you’ve built up an HSA, that can make COBRA cheaper than the letter looks.

What happens to the deductible I’ve already met? On COBRA you keep it. Federal rules say you keep credit for what you’ve paid toward the deductible this year, as if you’d never left the job. A new HealthCare.gov or private plan starts you back at zero. So if you’ve already paid most of this year’s deductible and you’re near the end of the plan year, staying on COBRA until it resets can cost less than switching, even at a higher premium.

The 60 days that decide everything

Losing job coverage opens a special enrollment period. You can sign up for a HealthCare.gov plan within 60 days of losing it, even outside open enrollment. Your plan also has to give you at least 60 days to decide whether to take COBRA, and at least 45 days after you sign up to make the first payment.

Is COBRA retroactive? Yes, if you sign up inside that window. The rules say your coverage then starts the day your job plan would have ended, so there’s no gap. The plan doesn’t have to pay bills from those weeks until you’ve signed up and paid, and a doctor’s office may be told you aren’t covered yet. Some healthy people use the window as a safety net and only sign up if they get hurt or sick. If you do that, watch the deadline. Once it passes, COBRA is gone.

This is where people get caught. If you take COBRA and then drop it, or just stop paying, that doesn’t open a new window. HealthCare.gov says, “Voluntarily dropping COBRA doesn’t count.” You’d wait for the next open enrollment unless something else happens, like a move or a new baby.

So decide inside the 60 days. Don’t pick COBRA because it’s easy and plan to switch later. When COBRA runs out on its own, you get another 60 days to pick a marketplace plan. Quitting it early is what costs you.

If you’re healthy and over the subsidy line

Over the line, a HealthCare.gov plan is full price too, so you’re comparing two full prices. These are the questions I’d go through.

  • Are you in the middle of treatment, or seeing doctors you can’t give up? Then COBRA keeps all of that the same, and it can be worth the money.
  • If not, a full-price ACA plan may cost less, especially a bronze plan with a health savings account. It covers conditions you already have, just like COBRA.
  • If you’re healthy and only need cover for a few months, a short-term plan can cost less still. I sell them in Florida, Arizona, Georgia, Indiana and South Carolina. They can ask about your health, turn you down and leave out conditions you already have, so I’d only use one if you know what it leaves out.

Is short-term health insurance a good idea between jobs?

It can be, if the gap is short and you’re healthy. But short-term plans aren’t ACA coverage, so they don’t change the 60-day rule. If you buy one and let your marketplace window close, you’re waiting for open enrollment to get back to an ACA plan. My page on whether private health insurance is worth it covers how to check one before you buy, and the page for people who make too much for a subsidy has 2027 full prices by age.

Will leaving the job drop me under the line?

Maybe. The subsidy line is drawn on your household income for the whole year, so a few months without a paycheck can pull you under it. If you’re retiring early, my page on health insurance before Medicare goes through it. If you’re going out on your own, the self-employed page does. COBRA never comes with a tax credit. A marketplace plan might, if your income for the year lands under the line.

Leaving a job? Let’s compare before your 60 days run out.

It’s a 30-minute call. Bring your COBRA letter and I’ll put it next to a full-price ACA plan and the private plans I can sell in your state. In Georgia I don’t enroll people in Georgia Access plans, but I’ll still walk you through one.

I'm the one who calls, at the time you pick. I don't sell your information or pass it to other agents.

Sources

  1. U.S. Department of Labor, Continuation of Health Coverage (COBRA) (employers with 20 or more employees; up to 102 percent of the cost to the plan) and An Employee’s Guide to Health Benefits Under COBRA (September 2022: at least 60 days to elect, at least 45 days to make the first payment). Read November 16, 2026.
  2. HealthCare.gov, COBRA coverage when you’re unemployed (60 days after losing job-based coverage; dropping COBRA voluntarily doesn’t qualify; 60 days when COBRA ends). Read November 16, 2026.
  3. KFF, Employer Health Benefits Survey 2025, Summary of Findings (average annual premiums $9,325 single and $26,993 family; the monthly COBRA figures are those times 1.02, divided by 12). Read November 17, 2026.
  4. CMS, QHP Landscape, individual market medical, plan year 2027: Miami-Dade County benchmark silver plan at 40 and 60, full price. Read November 16, 2026.
  5. 26 CFR 54.4980B-6, Q&A-3: an election made during the election period gives coverage from the date it would otherwise have been lost, and claims from the election period don’t have to be paid before the election and payment. Read November 20, 2026.
  6. 29 U.S.C. 1162(2)(A)(i): 18 months after a job ends or hours are cut. Read November 16, 2026. 1162(2)(A)(iv) and (viii), and 1163 (qualifying events, including the gross misconduct exception): 36 months for other events, 29 months on a Social Security disability finding in the first 60 days. Read November 18, 2026.
  7. IRS, Publication 969, “Insurance premiums” (an HSA can pay COBRA premiums and coverage while receiving unemployment compensation). Read November 18, 2026.
  8. 26 CFR 54.4980B-5, Q&A-2: someone who elects COBRA keeps credit for expenses already counted toward the plan’s deductibles. Read November 20, 2026.
  9. 26 U.S.C. 36B: the premium tax credit is figured on household income for the tax year. Read November 16, 2026.

Zach Bradford

Florida license W347851 • NPN 18181266

I’m Zach Bradford, an independent broker licensed in 8 states for health and life insurance only. I've been licensed since November 2016 and with Best Insurance Group since September 2021. When you call, you talk to me, not a call center.