Is Private Health Insurance Worth It? How to Check a Plan
If you make too much for a subsidy and you’re healthy, you’ve probably seen ads for private health insurance that costs a lot less than a HealthCare.gov plan. Some of those plans are real and worth a look. Some aren’t insurance at all. Here’s how I tell them apart, and the checks I’d run before paying anyone.
This page is for readers in the 8 states I’m licensed in: Florida, Michigan, North Carolina, Arizona, Texas, Georgia, Indiana, and South Carolina. It’s general information, not legal advice.
Got a plan in front of you already?
Send it my way. On a 30-minute call I’ll tell you what kind of plan it is, what it leaves out, and how it compares with a full-price HealthCare.gov plan in your county.
Book 30 minutes with meI'm the one who calls, at the time you pick. I don't sell your information or pass it to other agents.
What does “private health insurance” mean?
It gets used for two very different things, and most of the confusion starts there.
The first is an Affordable Care Act plan you buy straight from the insurance company instead of through HealthCare.gov. People call that off-exchange. It follows the same rules as a marketplace plan. It covers conditions you already have and can’t turn you down for your health. Over the subsidy line you wouldn’t get a tax credit either way, so the main difference is where you buy it.
The second is a plan that isn’t ACA coverage at all. You’ll see these called non-ACA or non-Obamacare plans. Short-term plans are the big one. They can ask about your health, turn you down, and leave out conditions you already have. Then there are plans that pay a set amount when something specific happens, like an accident, a listed illness or a night in the hospital. Those pay on top of real coverage. They don’t replace it.
Both kinds are legitimate insurance when a licensed company sells them. The trouble starts when the second kind gets sold as if it were the first.
Is it worth it if you’re healthy?
Sometimes. If you’re healthy, over the line and paying full price, a short-term plan can cost a lot less each month. I sell them in Florida, Arizona, Georgia, Indiana and South Carolina.
What you give up is the safety net. If you get sick while you’re on one, the condition you now have can be left out of the next plan you apply for, or you can be turned down. Each plan has a cap on what it pays, and some make you wait before they pay for an illness. A full-price ACA plan has none of those problems. That’s what the extra money buys.
So I ask two questions. Could you live with being stuck on whatever coverage you can get if your health changes? And would the savings still matter if you had a bad year? If the answer to the first is no, I’d stay with an ACA plan, and a bronze plan with a health savings account is often the cheapest one there.
Is it worth it if I’m pregnant or planning to be?
No. This is where I’d stay on an ACA plan. Every HealthCare.gov plan covers pregnancy and childbirth, even if you were already pregnant when it started. The short-term plans I sell leave out pregnancy except for complications.
Timing matters too. Being pregnant doesn’t let you sign up outside open enrollment. Having the baby does, and you get 60 days after the birth. So if a baby might come next year, pick the ACA plan now.
My page for people who make too much for a subsidy has the 2027 prices, how long a short-term plan can last in each state, and what the ones I sell leave out.
Is there cheaper health insurance for healthy people?
Yes, but not on HealthCare.gov. An ACA plan can’t charge you less for being healthy. Federal rules let its price change only with your age, where you live, tobacco use and whether it covers just you or your family. A marathon runner and someone with diabetes, same age and county, pay the same.
Plans that ask health questions work the other way. A short-term plan prices for people who pass its questions, and that’s why it can cost less. The catch is the same one I covered above: if your health changes, the next plan that asks questions can leave the condition out or turn you down. That’s the real decision, not just the monthly price.
Is private health insurance a scam? Five checks before you pay
Most of it isn’t. But the FTC has warned about ads that promise comprehensive health insurance when “the plan turns out to have limited benefits.” These are the checks I’d run on any plan, including one from me.
- Ask what kind of plan it is, and get the answer in writing. Is it an ACA plan, a short-term plan, or a plan that pays set amounts? Then read the brochure for three things: how it treats conditions you already have, the most it will pay, and any wait before it covers an illness. If the person selling it can’t answer, that tells you something.
- Make sure it’s insurance. A health care sharing ministry isn’t. North Carolina’s Department of Insurance says these plans “are NOT insurance,” that “there is no guarantee of payment on a claim,” and that it doesn’t regulate them. Some people choose one anyway. Just don’t let anyone sell you one as insurance.
- Look up the company. The NAIC’s Consumer Insurance Search finds insurance companies by name. The NAIC also tells you to check your state insurance department to confirm the company is licensed where you live. Do both.
- Look up the agent. The NAIC’s agent search is free and tells you whether a person is licensed to sell insurance. Mine is NPN 18181266, and you’re welcome to check it.
- Don’t pay to get on HealthCare.gov. The FTC’s advice is “Don’t pay for help enrolling.” It says to compare and sign up at the source, HealthCare.gov, or to call the Marketplace Call Center listed there.
One more. If someone pushes you to pay today, on the phone, before you’ve seen anything in writing, hang up. A real plan will still be there tomorrow.
Is private health insurance tax deductible?
It depends on how you earn your money, not on where you bought the plan.
If you’re self-employed, you can usually deduct your premiums before your income is even added up. That’s the best deal in the tax code for health insurance, and it can lower the income the subsidy line is drawn on. My page on self-employed health insurance covers the limits.
If you work for someone else, premiums you pay yourself count as a medical expense. The catch is you only get a deduction if you itemize, and only for the part of your medical bills over 7.5% of your adjusted gross income. On a $100,000 income, the first $7,500 of medical bills gets you nothing. Most people I talk to don’t clear it.
Plans that pay you a set amount are different. The IRS leaves out policies that pay you a guaranteed amount each week while you’re in the hospital. If you have one of those, ask a tax preparer before you count it.
When can I buy one?
ACA plans have open enrollment. On HealthCare.gov it started November 1, 2026, and a plan you pick by December 15 starts January 1. CMS says the window runs through January 15, 2027, but that end date is still being fought over in a federal appeal, so I’d treat December 15 as the real deadline. My open enrollment guide follows the case. The short-term plans I sell can be bought any time of year. Losing a job plan gives you 60 days to sign up for an ACA plan at any time of year, and my page on COBRA or private insurance covers that window. Retiring before Medicare? Here are your options until 65.
Want a second opinion on a plan?
It’s a 30-minute call. Bring the plan you’re looking at, or nothing at all, and I’ll put it next to a full-price ACA plan and the private plans I can sell in your state. In Georgia I don’t enroll people in Georgia Access plans, but I’ll still walk you through one.
I'm the one who calls, at the time you pick. I don't sell your information or pass it to other agents.
Sources
- 45 CFR 147.102(a)(1), what an ACA plan’s price may vary by: individual or family, rating area, age and tobacco use. Read November 18, 2026.
- FTC, The low-down on health insurance ads during open season (December 10, 2024) and How to avoid health insurance scams this open enrollment season (December 12, 2025). Read November 16, 2026.
- North Carolina Department of Insurance, Alternate Plans (health care sharing ministries). Read November 16, 2026.
- NAIC, Consumer Insurance Search and Insurance Agent/Broker Search. Read November 16, 2026.
- CMS and HealthCare.gov, 2027 open enrollment dates; City of Columbus v. Kennedy, No. 26-1938 (4th Cir.), Georgetown Law Health Care Litigation Tracker, argued October 30, 2026, no ruling as of November 16, 2026.
- IRS, Publication 502 (2025), Medical and Dental Expenses: premiums for policies that cover medical care count, the 7.5% of AGI floor, and the exclusion for policies that pay a guaranteed amount each week while you’re hospitalized. Read November 20, 2026.
- HealthCare.gov, Health coverage if you’re pregnant, plan to get pregnant, or recently gave birth: Marketplace plans cover pregnancy and childbirth even if the pregnancy began first; pregnancy isn’t a Special Enrollment Period, a birth is, with 60 days to apply. Read November 20, 2026.
Zach Bradford
Florida license W347851 • NPN 18181266
I’m Zach Bradford, an independent broker licensed in 8 states for health and life insurance only. I've been licensed since November 2016 and with Best Insurance Group since September 2021. When you call, you talk to me, not a call center.
